background image
38 Unfinished business: Koori women and the justice system
Case study 2: Annie
Coming into contact with
criminal justice system
"wrecked my life".
Annie acknowledges she broke
the law however, she says how
she was treated and what happened as a
result after first coming into contact with the
legal system, had ruined her life for years. She
said it had the following impact:
· She suffered abuse from the police while in
custody, which Annie believes was a result
of the negative view the police had towards
Koori people.
· She was not treated with respect and dignity.
· She was not listened to and felt that no
matter what she said, no one cared or took
the time to allow her to speak or tell her story.
· No one explained the legal system or how
things worked and what to expect. She was
fearful and felt lost and alone.
· She felt humiliated due to the above
treatment. She originally came from
interstate and had relocated to Victoria
and became a part of the community
in Victoria. However, the shame she
experienced affected her relationships in
both communities because, "everyone knows
everyone's business and word go around that
Annie was `in trouble'". Once this reputation
started she was not able to change anyone's
view of her, especially the Elders, which
caused Annie more shame. This was part of
the reason why Annie left the new community
she was living in and relocated.
· Her first contact with the police and then
with the wider legal system started a spiral
of breakdowns in Annie's life, resulting in
an increase of alcohol and drug use and
eventuating in the loss of her home and
her children through Department of Human
Services (DHS) involvement.
Annie stated that earning the respect of her
community was difficult when she had no
support to assist her to get her life together.
This reduced her ability to be seen as a
role model amongst her peers which was
something that was very important to her.
Annie believes that if she had been shown
support from the first point of contact with the
law (police) and then throughout her journey
in the legal system coming into contact with
Legal Aid, court system, things may not have
spiralled out of control in other areas of her life.
Annie believes if there were support services
to address her issues from the beginning she
would have taken it.
She believes that support should address the
following concerns:
· self-esteem issues, which are a big concern
among Koori women, who are entrenched
in dysfunctional relationships with partners
who are often involved in alcohol and drug
use and often these relationships centre
around domestic violence
· anger management
· parenting skills
· social skills and learning how to relate with
other people
· mental health issues and better education
amongst professionals, especially within
the police.
Annie also highlighted the need for stricter
measures around the issue of confidentiality
within Koori services. Annie stated that part
of the reason why she was anxious about
accessing an Indigenous-focused service
is because "people talk and the whole
community knows who you've seen, what
has been said and what your issues are".
Annie's experience with support workers in
the community has been negative due to this
reason and she says that confidentiality is not
as strict as it is in mainstream services.