background image
Page 14
www.thegreengazette.ca
July / August 2013
TheGreenGazette
Environmental Defence is urging the fed-
eral government and industry to take
measures to reduce Canadians' exposure
to toxic chemicals
A new report was recently released
demonstrating that Canadian children are
born pre-polluted. The new report, "Pre-
Polluted: A Report on Toxic Substances in
the Umbilical Cord Blood of Canadian
Newborns," found that Canadian babies
are being exposed to a slew of chemicals
while in the womb because the chemicals
are so pervasive in the environment and in
the products we use. Some of the chemi-
cals tested for are linked to serious health
issues such as cancer and developmental
and reproductive problems.
"This is evidence that our babies ­
who are extremely vulnerable ­ are being
burdened with a toxic chemical load be-
fore they are born," said Maggie Mac-
Donald, toxics program manager with
Environmental Defence. "Expectant moth-
ers can't protect themselves and their chil-
dren from toxic chemicals that are perva-
sive in our environment. That's why this
should be a wake-up call that strong action
from the government and industry is
needed."
Environmental Defence tested the
umbilical cord blood of three anonymous
newborns in the Greater Toronto Area and
Hamilton for PBDEs (flame retardants),
PCBs (a banned chemical), PFCs (found in
non-stick coatings), Organochlorine pesti-
cides, dioxins and furans, mercury, and
lead, which are chemicals that are known
to be pervasive in the environment.
"Some of these chemicals have
been banned for years but were still found
in test results. This is a serious concern
because it shows that these chemicals
remain in the environment decades after
being phased out," said MacDonald.
The tests found the following:
·
137 (45 per cent) of the310 chemicals
tested were detected in the cord blood
samples from the three babies, with a
range of between 55 and 121 for each
child
·
Of the 137 chemicals found in the
We Ignore Scientists at Our Peril
Science Matters
I
t's happening again. Research
confirms agreement among most
climate scientists that we are alter-
ing the Earth's climate, mainly by
burning fossil fuels. And industrial inter-
ests, backed by climate change deniers,
pull out every trick to sow doubt and con-
fusion. What will it take for us to start
seriously tackling the problem?
For the latest study, investigators
led by John Cook at Skeptical Science,
examined abstracts of 12,000 peer-
reviewed papers on climate science. They
also received comments from 1,200 scien-
tists, who rated more than 2,100 full stud-
ies. In both cases, more than 97 per cent of
studies that took a position on the causes of
global warming said human activity is a
primary factor. Less than one per cent re-
jected the consensus position. The results
are consistent with previous research.
As expected, deniers are out in full
force, many employing methods common
to those who reject science. Medical scien-
tists Pascal Diethelm and Martin McKee
examined these tactics in the European
Journal of Public Health: cherry picking,
making reference to fake experts, misrep-
resentation and logical fallacies, impossi-
ble expectations of what research can de-
liver, and conspiracy theories. Deniers
often rely on talking points spread by a
handful of usual suspects, including Chris-
topher Monckton in the UK, the Heartland
Institute and Anthony Watts in the US, and
Friends of Science and Tom Harris in Can-
ada.
The
Alberta-based
group
was
caught several years ago funnelling money
­ mostly from fossil fuel companies ­
through a "Science Education Fund" at the
University of Calgary. It was used to create
a disinformation campaign and video with
Harris, who then worked with PR firm
APCO Worldwide and now heads up an
organization called (ironically) the Interna-
tional Climate Science Coalition, which
rejects the scientific consensus on human-
caused climate change. According to Des-
mog Blog, Friends of Science has misrep-
resented the recent survey, calling it
"careless incitement of a misinformed and
frightened public, when in fact the sun is
the main driver of climate change; not hu-
man activity or carbon dioxide."
Another recent misrepresentation
concerns research by the UK Met Office,
which deniers falsely claim shows the
Earth hasn't warmed for 17 years.
Science isn't perfect, but it's one of
the best tools we have for understanding
our place in the cosmos. When people
around the world apply rigorous scientific
method to study our actions and their im-
pacts on the things that keep us alive and
By
David
Suzuki
healthy ­ clean air, water, and soil, and
biodiverse plants and animals ­ we must
listen, not just about climate, but about a
range of issues.
Many scientists are saying we're
creating serious problems--but we have
solutions. A recent statement, "Scientists'
Consensus on Maintaining Humanity's Life
Support Systems in the 21st Century," lists
five major challenges: climate disruption,
extinctions, loss of ecosystem diversity,
pollution, and human population growth
and resource consumption.
More than 2,200 have signed, stat-
ing, "As scientists who study the interaction
of people with the rest of the biosphere
using a wide range of approaches, we agree
that the evidence that humans are damaging
their ecological life-support systems is
overwhelming."
Some may claim this is "alarmist." It
is--because the situation is alarming. It
goes on: "For humanity's continued health
and prosperity, we all ­ individuals, busi-
nesses, political leaders, religious leaders,
scientists, and people in every walk of life ­
must work hard to solve these five global
problems starting today."
Many of the proposed solutions have
long been advocated by people working in
science, the environment, and even busi-
ness: conserving energy and reducing fossil
fuel use; better ecosystem management
through processes like natural capital
evaluation; improved food production and
distribution and waste reduction; regulating
and preventing pollution; and stabilizing
population growth through better education,
health care, family-planning services, eco-
nomic opportunities, and women's rights.
Humanity has changed direction before.
When our tools become outdated,
we invent new ones. It's why in many
countries, we no longer rely on slavery to
maintain economies, we can all vote re-
gardless of race or sex, and we enjoy longer
and healthier lives than before. Many sys-
tems we've invented don't apply to current
circumstances. We can and must change the
way we act. That requires listening to sci-
entists and those who are working on solu-
tions, and not to the naysayers and deniers
who would keep us stalled in a doomed
spiral.

Written with contributions from David Su-
zuki Foundation communications manager
Ian Hanington.

Learn more at
New Report Contains First of its Kind
Evidence that Canadian Children are
Born Pre-polluted with Toxic Chemicals
umbilical cord blood, 132 are reported
to cause cancer in humans or animals
·
110 of the chemicals are considered
toxic to the brain and nervous system
·
133 of the chemicals cause develop-
mental and reproductive problems in
mammals
A developing fetus is especially at
risk when it comes to exposure to these
chemicals, since it's growing rapidly and
lacks systems to process waste and flush
out toxins. Studies have shown that the
endocrine system (which regulates the
body's hormones) is more sensitive to the
effects of toxic exposures during certain
"windows of vulnerability" in human de-
velopment ­ especially gestation, infancy,
and puberty. In addition, very little is
known about the effects of these chemicals
in human bodies and the environment.
"Our findings are only the tip of the iceberg
when it comes to toxins in our children and
the
environment,"
said
MacDonald.
"Further research on the toxic body
burden of Canadian newborns needs to
happen, and the results be made public, to
understand the scope of this issue."
Environmental Defence, the organi-
zation that successfully advocated the ban-
ning of Bisphenol A (BPA) in baby bottles
and phthalates in toys, is urging Health
Canada and industry to remove harmful
chemicals from products. It is also asking
the government to establish clear, strict
timelines for removing chemicals for which
phase-outs have been announced from the
marketplace, and to test chemicals used in
consumer products for toxic effects before
they can be sold to Canadians.
The Environmental Defence report,
"Pre-Polluted: A Report on Toxic Sub-
stances in the Umbilical Cord Blood of
Canadian Newborns," can be downloaded
at
environmentaldefence.ca/prepolluted
.
Environmental Defence is Canada's
most effective environmental action organi-
zation. We challenge and inspire change in
government, business, and people to ensure
a greener, healthier, and prosperous life for
all.
The Toxic Ten -
personal care products
TRICLOSA - Found in: Products
labelled `antibacterial, such as antiper-
siperants/deodorants, cleansers, and
hand sanitizers.

ARTIFICAL MUSKS - (Nitromusks
such as musk xylene, musk ketone)
Found in: Some products that contain
fragrance or parfum, various hair prod-
ucts, moisturizers, cosmetics, even
those labelled "unscented".

PARABE S - (Ethylparaben, Methyl-
paraben, Butylparaben, or Propylpara-
ben) Found in: Various cosmetics and
moisturizers.

PHTHALATES - Found in: Nail prod-
ucts, and scented products.

PETROLATUM - (Pertoleum Jelly)
Found in: various lip, skin, and hair
products.

FORMALDEHYDE RELEASI G
AGE TS - (Quaternium-15, 1,4-
Dioxane, DMDM Hydantoin, Diazolid-
iny l Urea, Im idazo lid iny l Ure a,
Methenamine, and Sodium Hydro-
methyiglycinate.) Found in: Various
hair products, moisturizers, and cosmet-
ics.

SODIUM LAURETH SULFATE &
SODIUM LAURYL SULFATE -
Found in: Products that lather like
shampoo, toothpaste, and body wash.

S I L I C O
E C H E M I C A L S -
(Cyclomethicone, Cydotetraslloxane,
Cyclopentaslloxane, Cyclohexasllox-
ane. Found in: Various hair products,
moisturizers, and cosmetics.

COAL TAR DERIVED COLOURS -
(P-Phenylenediamine PPD) Found in:
Hair dye.

BHA & BHT - Found in: Moisturizers,
makeup, and some fragrances.
www.justbeautiful.ca
Credit: Union of Concerned Scientists